How to Support Effective and Engaging Structured Independent Reading Time in Your Classroom
Independent reading is a student’s reading of a text on his or her own. It can occur anywhere- as part of an activity in a school classroom or at home and includes books that are appropriate for the student’s reading level. Independent reading has shown to be an effective complement to other reading programs in school, not only in helping students practice and develop reading skills but in fostering a greater love for reading that may carry through at home. This article discusses how to foster reading skills and strategies through independent reading.
WHAT INDEPENDENT READING LOOKS LIKE
During independent reading, students have selected a “just right book” at their independent reading level, allowing for some ownership of their reading since they choose the book themselves. Students aren’t moving around- they have selected a spot to read in the classroom and settle in to read silently to themselves for the entire independent reading block, which typically lasts between 15 and 30 minutes in many classes. As students read, the teacher is circling the room, monitoring student’s reading and checking in on them to help support reading skills and strategies. The teacher may sit down next to a student and ask the student to read aloud in a whisper to her or may ask some specific questions on a topic in a given page of the book. The teacher may be recording her observations on a chart as she walks the room and monitors students, and may use this to inform her on who to check in with the next day.
WHY IS INDEPENDENT READING IMPORTANT?
Providing your students with independent reading time in your classroom allows students to develop reading comprehension and practice the strategies necessary to understand the text they are reading. In addition, when reading “just right books”, students can improve their fluency and their vocabulary in an environment that is low stress and enjoyable. Many teachers feel that the benefits of independent reading go beyond improvement of reading skills: the more exposure students have to read, especially when they take part in the book selection process and choose books at their appropriate reading level, the more opportunities they have to discover that reading can be fun and enjoyable.
Choosing an appropriate reading level
When participating in independent reading, students should work from books that are at their “independent” reading level. In other words, they should read books with an accuracy of about 96%- or only 4% of errors and thus can read the book without help. If books are too challenging, students will not be motivated to persevere, and will not develop a love for reading. If books are too easy, students won’t have any opportunities to practice reading strategies to help them increase their reading fluency and comprehension over time. This applies to students of ALL grade levels- from elementary students through high school students! When planning your independent reading block for your classroom, first determine how you will measure your student’s independent reading level. A formal assessment to determine your student’s reading level is important- not only for independent reading time but for your other literacy blocks as well. There are many ways to assess student reading level, and though this article does not discuss how to assess students in detail, you should learn more about assessing reading levels or determine which methods are used in your school. Some common methods of determining reading level are: Fountas and Pinnell Guided Reading Levels, Lexile Levels, ATOS and DRA. You can also determine an estimate of reading level by student grade level, using a “conversion chart” like our Lexile Conversion Chart, available for download below.
If you are unable to assess students in a formal method, a quick approach to estimating reading ability is the “five finger rule”. Ask students to turn to any page in a book they wish to read. For every word they don’t know, they should hold up a finger. Students should select a book that contains approximately 2-3 words they don’t know in any given page. This ensures that students don’t choose a book where they know all words (too easy) and don’t choose a book where they cannot understand the majority of the text (too hard). Instead they choose a book where they don’t know some words that will allow them success in understanding the text but also allow them to practice comprehension and decoding strategies.
Once you and your students understand their independent reading level, you should make sure students have plenty of access to books at their level that they can choose from. Many teachers invest in their own classroom libraries, including texts of many books at varying reading levels. Other teachers may not have their own libraries but can arrange to take students to the school library to select an appropriate text. If you need help in selecting books at reading levels appropriate for your classroom, you can use a resource like Scholastic’s book wizard to help you find books specific to your grade level or reading level:
https://www.scholastic.com/teachers/bookwizard/ Build book selection into your classroom literacy block to allow students an appropriate amount of time to select a book at their level and within their interests to ensure the highest chance of success for each student.
Check in 1: How to Support Comprehension in Your Independent Reading Block
Once students have selected their books and have settled into their independent reading time, begin checking in with students. You should have a plan in place on the students you wish to target first in the block, with additional students if time allows. You can sit or stand close to your student and ask him to read aloud a paragraph to you. Listen for reading errors and correct any errors immediately. Then, ask 1-2 questions about the paragraph to gauge the student’s comprehension. This should be strategic and formulaic: You should have a plan in place for specific comprehension skills you’d like to check on and reinforce. For example, you may ask a question about how the paragraph relates to something in the student’s life, or something from class to allow connections between the text and the real world. You may want to reinforce the idea of tone or author’s purpose and may ask what the student feels the author is trying to convey in the paragraph. Note your student's answer and whether the student needs additional support so that you can reinforce the ideas later in another literacy activity.
Check in 2: How to Support Vocabulary Development in Your Independent Reading Block
Select a page or a chapter for the student to read and identify a vocabulary word he doesn’t understand. You may ask the student to annotate sentences surrounding the difficult word, or write it down in a graphic organizer or notebook. Assign a specific strategy to the student to help identify the unknown word. For example, you may ask the student to practice a context clue learned in class or use the dictionary to look up the unknown word. You can also ask the student to write down the unknown word’s definition in a running vocabulary log. These practices will reinforce to students the importance of learning new words using a variety of strategies to determine their meaning and will help build their comprehension and fluency over time.
Check in 3: Integrate Teaching and Discussion into Your Independent Reading Block
In a third check in, focus on a targeted teaching point. You may either focus a teaching point on something you addressed in a mini- lesson with the whole class, or you may have identified certain students that are weak in certain areas and need additional assistance. Conference with your students and assign students a task specific to the pages, chapter, or book they have read so far. For example, if a teaching point is reviewing summarizing book details in order, ask students to either write down on composition paper a summary of the book’s chapter or to verbally discuss it with you. During your conference, support the student in areas where he is still struggling and then determine the next day’s teaching discussion- whether you need to focus on that area or move on to another area for practice.
Using a form or checklist to help you quickly plan your independent reading time is a must, and a sample is available for download below. Use this alongside a data collection tracker you use in class to keep records of your student’s progress during independent reading time- whether this is academic progress, or a tracker on how many pages/ books the student has read during independent study, these practices will help motivate students to continue to improve in their reading.
*Note that each check in does not necessarily need to relate to the same page or paragraph and can even be spread over multiple days. Build a plan for yourself-whether you select a small group of students each day to perform all three check ins, completing your rotation of all students by the end of the week, or whether you decide to check in with the entire class each day focusing on one or two check- ins. The key is to determine the plan that will work best for your students and stick to it- showing students you expectations for them when they read, and reinforcing the right strategies to make all students successful.
LEXILE CONVERSION CHART - This Chart to allows teachers to approximate which books are appropriate for students to read during independent reading time when the five finger rule, running records data, or other information is not available.
INDEPENDENT READING FORM - This form allows teachers to plan how they will structure independent reading time for individual students and plan a focus for the next day.
Go back to the classroom and try this:
- Select 5-8 students for your next class that you feel need reinforcement of some reading strategies, or additional reading support. Remember that you can still monitor other students, but you will focus more attention on your selected students.
- Using the provided Independent Reading Form, verify that your students are currently reading books that are appropriate to their independent reading level- books that are too easy will not help them practice reading skills and strategies; however, books that are too difficult will frustrate students and turn them away from reading.
- Plan how you will check for comprehension, vocabulary practice, and allow for teaching & discussion for your specific targeted students and plan a strategy for checking in with all students using the provided form.
- Implement this form into your independent reading time over the next week, modifying the focus of your day’s support based on what you learn about your students in a given day. Be sure to develop a plan to support all students in your class within the week.
- At the end of the week, reflect on what you learned about each student and how that can help you plan for future lessons and reading activities. Refine your approach to supporting students during independent reading time and continue to reflect on and improve your plan until you find something right for you and your students.
Hiebert, E.H., & Reutzel, D. R. (Eds.) (2010). Revisiting silent reading: New directions for teachers and researchers. Newark, DE: International Reading Association.
Kelley, M.J., & Clausen-Grace, N. (2009, December). Facilitating engagement by differentiating independent reading. The Reading Teacher, 63(4), 313–318.
To select books at the appropriate grade level/ reading level for your students:
To read more on Independent Reading:
RELATED PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT COURSES FROM MODEL TEACHING:
(5 Hours) Participants in this course will learn what typical writing looks like for kindergarten through third grade students, as well as some common writing tasks they can be expected to accomplish. This course will also cover the purpose of both holistic and analytic rubrics, and when each type is appropriate to use for assessment of student writing. Participants will also learn how to develop their own rubrics to use to monitor the progress of their students’ writing skills.
TEACHING STUDENTS TO USE TEXT ANNOTATION & TEXT EVIDENCE
ONLINE PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT TRAINING COURSE
(5 Hours) In this course, teachers will learn how to teach their students the importance of making thoughtful text annotations and using context clues to deepen understanding of a particular text and uncover the meaning of unfamiliar words. Teachers will learn how to instruct students at multiple grade levels, proper annotation techniques that will ultimately help their students respond more effectively on writing assignments. In addition, participants will learn how to set a purpose for their students when reading a new text, as well as how to assess the depth of their understanding through crafted writing prompts and assessment questions.
SUPPORTING READING INSTRUCTION FOR ELEMENTARY LEARNERS
ONLINE PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT TRAINING COURSE
Participants in this course will be exposed to a variety of methods to determine a student’s reading level, with the focus on Fountas and Pinnell’s Benchmark Assessment System, and their accompanying guide to reading behaviors. The training will provide specific ideas for mini-lessons, classroom activities, graphic organizers and anchor charts that will allow teachers to provide instruction for their students in order to help them progress to higher reading levels.
INTRO TO GUIDED READING: A GUIDE TO SMALL GROUP LITERACY INSTRUCTION
ONLINE PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT TRAINING COURSE
Participants in this course will learn about foundational reading skills and how they build upon one another, as well as understanding their relationship to a student’s reading level. The training will cover the background and main components of guided reading, as well as how to plan for a guided reading group. Participants will be provided with a variety of strategy ideas and resources they can implement immediately with their small groups.